Adventures in Amish Friendship Bread

I’m not a cook.

I can make a few things. Spinach and cream cheese lasagna, Eggs Florentine (I live in Florence, and this is one of the few things I can make, so I find it funny), and pretty good sandwiches- I count sandwiches as cooking! I can even make a mean “healthified” crock pot macaroni and cheese. It’s safe to say that Clay does 95% of the cooking around here.

I grew up in a household with a mom who loved to cook and bake, along with two grandmas less than 10 minutes away who also loved it. I was well fed, but I was also an only child and very involved, so I never learned how to cook. In college, I lived off of Taco Bell, Subway, whatever I could grab at the campus events I covered for the student newspaper- usually free pizza, and Wesley Foundation food (Wesley Foundation is like a youth group for college kids in which I served as a student leader).

Old School Wesley Foundation Pic

OLD OLD School Wesley Foundation Pic- Circa 2006, at the annual barbeque.

Junior year, I lived with three other Wesley Foundation girls in a villa, and every Tuesday night after Wesley Foundation, we got dibs on the leftovers because all of us were so involved and happened to live together. It’s amazing how far we could stretch leftover church food. Pretty soon I started dating Clay, who moved out of campus housing and regularly cooked. He was quite a score- living off campus AND able to cook :).

Clay and I at the Alumni Association Dinner in 2007

Clay and I at the Alumni Association Dinner in 2007. We weren't alumni yet, but I think this picture made it into several campus publications. It didn't hurt that I worked for the PR office...

A couple years ago, I guess I realized I was growing up and set some goals for myself, and one of them was to become more comfortable in the kitchen. I still hate to cook, but I do love baking and have made some pretty neat creations. I’ve even learned how to make recipes healthier by using Greek yogurt or applesauce instead of oil and whole wheat flour. Cooking still makes me anxious, but baking and making desserts- that’s relaxing.

A few weeks ago, my friend Rachel made Amish Friendship Bread, which is a recipe that involves mushing a bag of dough for 10 days, adding ingredients, making other bags of dough to give to your friends (hence- friendship bread), and baking the actual bread. She had four bags of starter dough to give away, so I definitely took her up on the offer. According to folklore, only the Amish have the recipe for the starter, and since the Amish don’t have Google, they can continue to believe that ;).

Me with the Amish Bread Starter

Giving this Amish Friendship Bread a Try!

Rachel gave me the starter, and I mushed and added ingredients for ten days. I didn’t know how this would work out, because I like instant gratification and waiting ten days just to bake the bread is pretty tough! I held out, and on the 10th day, I made Amish Friendship Muffins using the same recipe as the bread (with Greek yogurt instead of oil and whole wheat flour instead of white). They were delicious, and my coworkers really liked them :).

Amish Muffins

Amish Friendship Muffins- Because Muffins are Easier to Share!

Thanks to finding an awesome modification on Google (remember, don’t tell the Amish- it’s our secret!), I only made one starter, which I gave to my mom. She’s giving it back to me when she bakes her bread, and I’m contemplating making chocolate muffins with it like Rachel did.

We’ll see how it goes!

This entry was posted in Learning to Cook and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Adventures in Amish Friendship Bread

  1. gogirlinsc says:

    I loved this. I have a starter kit that’s in my freezer that I just might have to pull out now…. lol

    • Amy Lauren says:

      Yep, you can freeze the starters :). I will have one in a few days when I bake my bread, my mom gave me my new starter yesterday when I saw my parents. Only a few days of mushing and then muffins, haha.

  2. Lindsay says:

    I don’t mind to bake – the results are so rich! Cooking, meh. Josh does a good bit of cooking so I lucked out too! In college I was all about ramen or easy Mac. Cookin skillzzzz.

    • Amy Lauren says:

      Haha, in college I typical ate kraft dinner and drank diet cokes. Definitely not a healthy diet or lifestyle. I eat better now but I still don’t cook!

      Ramen… icky! Never!

  3. Pingback: Valentine’s Day and Shameless Self-Care |

  4. Pingback: Amish Friendship Bread | pv31woman

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s